If you have ultra-oily skin and you're into Asian beauty, chances are you’ve already heard of the Innisfree Matte Mineral Setting Powder. It’s a cult favorite that promises long-lasting mattification without flashback, basically a holy grail for those of us who are perpetually shiny.

Let’s start with the good. This powder absolutely delivers on its main claim. My skin stayed impressively matte for a full 8 hours without any blotting or reapplication, an achievement for anyone with oily skin. And at around $11, the price point is hard to beat. It’s lightweight, easy to apply, and doesn’t feel cakey. For oil control alone, it really does live up to the hype.

Now, the downside. Unfortunately, this powder only comes in one so-called universal shade and that’s where things start to unravel. On my medium-tan skin, the finish was noticeably grey and chalky. Instead of blending into my base, it sat on top, making my makeup appear two shades lighter. I even had someone ask if I was feeling okay because I looked a little off.

While the powder doesn’t technically cause flashback, the grey-white cast showed up harshly in photos and in person. I tried using it sparingly under the eyes the next day, hoping it might work as a subtle brightener, but it had the same ghostly effect.

Overall, this could be a great mattifying powder if you have fair to light skin. But for anyone medium and deeper, the lack of true translucency is a dealbreaker. It’s frustrating that there’s still only one shade offered, especially when so many brands have started expanding their ranges.

I'd say this is 4/10 with great oil control, but the color payoff makes it unusable for a lot of people. Definitely a pass for me, and a reminder that even mattifying powders need to be more inclusive.