Introduction: My Search for the Perfect Soft Eyeliner

Not sure which category this fits into, but I put a lot of effort into this lol.

Eyeliner can totally change your whole face, so I think it kinda makes sense to put it here? 

Gonna edit the pics and add them in later!

Hope this helps!

As someone who loves a subtle, natural eyeliner look, finding the perfect formula has been a long journey. Many eyeliners are too harsh, too smudgy, or too difficult to control. But after testing countless options, I finally found a hidden gem: Too Cool for School Dusk.

This eyeliner has completely changed my makeup routine, and in this detailed review, I’ll break down why it works, how it compares to Clio’s Vanilla Beige, and why you might want to add it to your collection.

Packaging & First Impressions

The Too Cool for School Dusk eyeliner comes in a sleek, minimalistic retractable pencil with a fine tip. It has a lightweight feel, and the twisting mechanism is smooth, allowing you to control how much product comes out easily.

✅ No need for a sharpener, which is a plus.

✅ Sturdy enough that I haven’t had issues with it breaking.

✅ Matte finish on the body makes it easy to grip.

At first glance, the liner looks like a basic, neutral brown eyeliner, but once applied, you immediately notice the difference.

Formula & Application: What Makes It Special?

This eyeliner is specifically designed for soft definition, particularly for the outer corner of the eye to create a subtle, natural lift.

✨ Key Features:

✔️ Glides on effortlessly – No tugging or pulling on the delicate eye area.

✔️ Soft but buildable color – Looks natural but can be layered for slightly more definition.

✔️ Not too creamy, not too dry – A perfect balance that allows for precision but doesn’t smudge easily.

✔️ Doesn’t break easily – Unlike many retractable eyeliners, this one holds its shape well.

The application is quick and foolproof, even for beginners. If you love the K-beauty style of soft eyeliner or the "invisible eyeliner" trend, this pencil makes it easy to achieve that look.

Color & Finish: The Perfect Muted Brown

One of the biggest selling points of this eyeliner is the unique shade.

Dusk is a soft, muted brown—not too warm, not too cool.

It enhances your natural features without looking harsh.

The finish is matte, which adds to the seamless, natural look.

Unlike traditional black eyeliners, which can look too intense for daytime or no-makeup makeup looks, Dusk provides just enough definition to make your eyes stand out without looking overdone.

Longevity & Smudge Test

One of my biggest concerns with eyeliners is staying power. I have oily eyelids, so a lot of eyeliners tend to smudge or fade throughout the day.

× How Dusk Holds Up:

✅ 8+ hours of wear with minimal fading

✅ Doesn’t transfer to my upper lid (huge win!)

✅ No raccoon eyes by the end of the day

✅ Water-resistant but not fully waterproof

* Pro Tip: If you have very oily eyelids, set it with a tiny bit of translucent powder or a matte eyeshadow in a similar shade to lock it in place even longer.

Comparison: Too Cool for School Dusk vs. Clio Vanilla Beige

Both Dusk and Clio Vanilla Beige are great choices for soft eyeliner, but they have some key differences.

✨ My Verdict?

✅ If you want an eyeliner that gives soft definition without harshness, Dusk is the winner.

✅ If you prefer something for aegyo-sal or a super subtle effect, Vanilla Beige is better suited.

Who Should Buy This?

This eyeliner is perfect for you if:

✔️ You love natural, soft eye makeup looks.

✔️ You struggle with harsh black eyeliners looking too intense.

✔️ You want a foolproof, everyday eyeliner that doesn’t smudge.

✔️ You prefer a product that’s easy to control and apply.

❌ If you love thick, bold eyeliner or need something ultra-waterproof, this might not be your best choice. But for day-to-day wear, it’s a must-have.

Final Thoughts: Worth the Hype?

Absolutely. Too Cool for School Dusk is one of those underrated gems that deserves more attention. It’s effortless, beginner-friendly, and perfect for anyone who wants soft definition without the commitment of a heavy liner.

???? Rating: 9.5/10 ????

✔️ Beautiful color

✔️ Great longevity

✔️ Smooth, easy application

✔️ No smudging

❌ Not waterproof (but still lasts long)

Would I repurchase? Absolutely. I’ve already stocked up on a backup. If you’re looking for a soft eyeliner that enhances your eyes without overpowering your look, give this one a try!